10 Best Tia Maria Substitutes

Have you ever found yourself crafting a cocktail only to realize you’re out of Tia Maria? I’ve been there. So, I did some trial and error and explored various substitutes for this classic coffee liqueur.

Now, I’m sharing my discoveries, focusing on alternatives that capture the essence of Tia Maria without compromising on flavors. If you’re looking for the best Tia Maria substitute, below are my top picks!

7. J.F. Haden’s Espresso Liqueur

Average Price: Approx. $34.99/750ml (MSRP)

Alcohol Content: 30% ABV

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why I Like It: This coffee liqueur is a powerhouse of flavor, exuding a rich coffee profile with a noticeable kick. Its higher ABV makes it a must-have bottle for those who like their drinks robust.

It’s made from 100% authentic Espresso, one of the best Tia Maria substitutes for making Espresso Martini and White Russian.